Water/ice distinction using time-of-flight (TOF) neutron imaging

Attenuation cross section of water and ice
Neutron attenuation cross section for super-cooled water and ice as a function of wavelength. Reproduced with permission from M. Siegwart et al., Rev. Sci. Instrum. 90, 103705 (2019). Copyright (2019), AIP Publishing.

The successful start-up of polymer electrolyte fuel cell stacks (PEFCs) under sub-zero conditions (cold-start) with a minimal input of auxiliary power is an important requirement for the broad market introduction of fuel cell cars. Typically, cold start failures occur when the water produced by the electrochemical reaction freezes and blocks the access of oxygen to the catalyst. However, water produced by the reaction in sub-zero conditions can remain in liquid (super-cooled) state. Methods that allow visualizing the location of freezing events during cold-starts help to understand which parameters influence the phase transitions. To this purpose, we take advantage of the fact that the attenuation for ice and super-cooled water differ at low neutron energies (long wavelengths) while while they are almost identical at high energies.

When water freezes in the pores of the GDL its volume expands in all directions and the density decreases. To account for the density change, we use time-of-flight neutron imaging (TOF-NI) and record images in two different energy windows - one corresponding to high and the other to low energy neutrons. This way a relative attenuation image is obtained, which allows for determining the aggregate state (liquid or frozen).

Neutron images of six GDLs. Partially filled with water/ice. (a) ice (b) partially ice, partially liquid water, (c) liquid (super-cooled) water. Left: High energy attenuation. Right: Ratio between low and high energy attenuation.

TOF-NI is conventionally using short pulses of neutron beam at a pulsed neutron source or produced with a rotating chopper disk with a narrow slit. This allows for discriminating the neutron wavelengths according to their travel time from the disk to the detector, as the speed of neutrons is wavelength dependent. The new proposed concept uses broad neutron pulses, which strongly increases the flux in comparison to conventional TOF imaging, at the cost of wavelength resolution.  With this method, we can clearly distinguish between super-cooled water and ice with:

  • A high contrast reaching approximately 6%
  • A good time resolution reaching one minute when averaging over a few square millimeters
  • Siegwart M, Woracek R, Márquez Damián JI, Tremsin AS, Manzi-Orezzoli V, Strobl M, et al.
    Distinction between super-cooled water and ice with high duty cycle time-of-flight neutron imaging
    Review of Scientific Instruments. 2019; 90(10): 103705 (15 pp.). https://doi.org/10.1063/1.5110288
  • Stahl P, Biesdorf J, Boillat P, Friedrich KA
    An investigation of PEFC sub-zero startup: evidence of local freezing effects
    Journal of the Electrochemical Society. 2016; 163(14): F1535-F1542. https://doi.org/10.1149/2.0771614jes
  • Biesdorf J, Oberholzer P, Bernauer F, Kaestner A, Vontobel P, Lehmann EH, et al.
    Dual spectrum neutron radiography: Identification of phase transitions between frozen and liquid water
    Physical Review Letters. 2014; 112(24): 248301. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.112.248301