Skip to main content
  • Paul Scherrer Institut PSI
  • PSI Research, Labs & User Services

Digital User Office

  • Digital User Office
  • DE
  • EN
  • FR
Paul Scherrer Institut (PSI)
Suche
Paul Scherrer Institut (PSI)

Hauptnavigation

  • Research at PSIOpen mainmenu item
    • Research Initiatives
    • Research Integrity
    • Scientific Highlights
    • Scientific Events
    • Scientific Career
    • PSI-FELLOW
    • PSI Data Policy
  • Research Divisions and LabsOpen mainmenu item
    • Overview
    • Research with Neutrons and Muons
    • Photon Science
    • Energy and Environment
    • Nuclear Energy and Safety
    • Biology and Chemistry
    • Large Research Facilities
  • Facilities and InstrumentsOpen mainmenu item
    • Overview
    • Large Research Facilities
    • Facilities
    • PSI Facility Newsletter
  • PSI User ServicesOpen mainmenu item
    • User Office
    • Methods at the PSI User Facilities
    • Proposals for beam time
    • Proposal Deadlines
    • Data Analysis Service (PSD)
    • EU support programmes
  • DE
  • EN
  • FR

Digital User Office (mobile)

  • Digital User Office

You are here:

  1. PSI Home
  2. Labs & User Services
  3. PSD
  4. LSF
  5. PHOENIX Group
  6. Scientific Highlights
  7. Are supersaturated calcium carbonate solutions classical or non-classical

Secondary navigation

Group PHOENIX

  • People
  • Scientific Highlights
  • Publications
27 February 2018

Are supersaturated calcium carbonate solutions classical or non-classical ?

Left: X-ray absorption spectra from supersaturated calcium carbonate solutions taken with a liquid microjet at the PHOENIX beamline. Comparison of the spectra with theoretical modeling shows the dominance of various ion pairs in solution, as expected in a classical solution. Right: image of liquid microjet in PHOENIX endstation.
Left: X-ray absorption spectra from supersaturated calcium carbonate solutions taken with a liquid microjet at the PHOENIX beamline. Comparison of the spectra with theoretical modeling shows the dominance of various ion pairs in solution, as expected in a classical solution. Right: image of liquid microjet in PHOENIX endstation.

Despite its widespread occurrence in nature and its importance in a variety of industrial applications, the nucleation and subsequent crystallization of calcium carbonate is still a matter of debate. Classical theory predicts that supersaturated carbonate solutions consist mostly of ions and ion pairs, with a small number of larger clusters present in the solution. The population of the different sized clusters in a solution is solely defined by the cluster’s size dependent Free Energy. If clusters are large enough they serve as nucleation germs for a new solid phase. The nucleation occurs once the surface free energy barrier posed by the new solid-liquid interface is overcome by the free energy win from bulk phase growth. However, for calcium carbonate solutions, this classical view has been challenged by the emergence of non-classical theories. The most predominant of these non-classical theories postulate that calcium carbonate solutions contain oligomeric species in amounts exceeding predictions from classical solution models and the agglomeration of these oligomers result in crystal nucleation and growth. In a novel experiment, using synchroton X-ray absorption spectroscopy, the molecular structure around the solvated calcium ion in dilute supersaturated calcium carbonate solutions was probed in situ. The results obtained definitively show that supersaturated calcium carbonate solutions are dominated by ions and ion pairs. The presence of larger oligomers as predicted by non-classical theories was not detected. Moreover, predictions from independent theoretical calculations on the structure of supersaturated calcium carbonate solutions were in congruence with the experimental results. As a consequence, it is quite clear that the nucleation of calcium carbonate follows a classical pathway. Apart from offering new insights into a fundamental and ubiquitous process, this research also unveils state of the art techniques for both experimental and theoretical calculations. The diversity of the team of scientists with different viewpoints and experiences played a key role in addressing this important research question. The team consisted of theoreticians from DOE’s Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, University of Minnesota and experimentalists from Paul Scherrer Institut in Switzerland.

Contact
Dr. Thomas Huthwelker
Swiss Light Source
Paul Scherrer Institut
Telephone: +41 56 310 5314
E-mail: thomas.huthwelker@psi.ch


Dr. Christopher J. Mundy
Physical Sciences Division, Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, Richland, WA 99354, USA and Department of Chemical Engineering, University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98195, USA.
E-mail: chris.mundy@pnnl.gov


Dr. James J. De Yoreo
Physical Sciences Division, Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, Richland, WA 99354, USA and Department of Materials Science and Engineering, University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98195, USA.
E-mail: james.deyoreo@pnnl.gov
Original Publication
Supersaturated calcium carbonate solutions are classical
Katja Henzler, Evgenii O. Fetisov, Mirza Galib, Marcel D. Baer,Benjamin A. Legg, Camelia Borca, Jacinta M. Xto, Sonia Pin, John L. Fulton, Gregory K. Schenter, Niranjan Govind, J. Ilja Siepmann, Christopher J. Mundy, Thomas Huthwelker, James J. De Yoreo
Science Advances, 26 Jan 2018
DOI: 10.1126/sciadv.aao6283

Sidebar

Associated Beamlines

  • PHOENIX / X07MB

Contact

Dr. Thomas Huthwelker
Paul Scherrer Institut
5232 Villigen-PSI
Switzerland
Telephone:
+41 56 310 5314
E-mail:
thomas.huthwelker@psi.ch

LSF Homepage

Laboratory for Synchrotron Radiation and Femtochemistry

Swiss Light Source SLS

Synchrotron light large research facility.


SwissFEL

The new X-ray free electron laser facility.
 

top

Footer

Paul Scherrer Institut

Forschungsstrasse 111
5232 Villigen PSI
Switzerland

Telephone: +41 56 310 21 11
Telefax: +41 56 310 21 99

How to find us
Contact form

Visitor Centre psi forum
School Lab iLab (in German)
Center for Proton Therapy
PSI Education Centre
PSI Guest House
PSI Gastronomie (in German)

 

Service & Support

  • Phone Book/People Search
  • User Office
  • Accelerator Status
  • PSI Publications
  • Suppliers
  • E-Billing
  • Computing
  • Safety (in German)

Career

  • Working at PSI
  • Job Opportunities
  • Training and further education
  • Vocational Training (in German)
  • PSI Education Center

For the media

  • PSI in brief
  • Facts and Figures
  • Media Contact
  • Media Releases
  • Social Media Newsroom

Follow us: Twitter (in English) LinkedIn Youtube Issuu RSS

Footer legal

  • Imprint
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Editors' login